Difference between revisions of "Open Problems:19"

From Open Problems in Sublinear Algorithms
Jump to: navigation, search
 
(One intermediate revision by one other user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
{{Header
 
{{Header
|title=Sketching vs. Streaming
 
 
|source=kanpur06
 
|source=kanpur06
 
|who=D. Sivakumar
 
|who=D. Sivakumar
Line 8: Line 7:
 
#''Simultaneous Communication:'' Both players send a message simultaneously to a third party who then has to compute $f(x,y)$.
 
#''Simultaneous Communication:'' Both players send a message simultaneously to a third party who then has to compute $f(x,y)$.
  
Obviously any function that can be evaluated with $B$ bits of communication in the simultaneous model can be evaluated in the one-way model with $B$ bits of communication. Are there natural functions that require significantly more communication in the simultaneous model than in the one-way model? It is known that any total, permutation-invariant function that can be computed in the one-way model can be computed in the simultaneous model. See {{cite|FeldmanMSSS-06}} for further details.
+
Obviously any function that can be evaluated with $B$ bits of communication in the simultaneous model can be evaluated in the one-way model with $B$ bits of communication. Are there natural functions that require significantly more communication in the simultaneous model than in the one-way model? It is known that any total, permutation-invariant function that can be computed in the one-way model but cannot be computed in the simultaneous model. See {{cite|FeldmanMSSS-06}} for further details.

Latest revision as of 05:21, 27 June 2022

Suggested by D. Sivakumar
Source Kanpur 2006
Short link https://sublinear.info/19

Show that any symmetric function that admits a good streaming algorithm also admits a sketching algorithm. In terms of communication complexity, consider trying to evaluate a symmetric function $f(x,y)$ in each of the following models:

  1. One-Way Communication: The player knowing $x$ sends a single message to the player knowing $y$ who then has to compute $f(x,y)$.
  2. Simultaneous Communication: Both players send a message simultaneously to a third party who then has to compute $f(x,y)$.

Obviously any function that can be evaluated with $B$ bits of communication in the simultaneous model can be evaluated in the one-way model with $B$ bits of communication. Are there natural functions that require significantly more communication in the simultaneous model than in the one-way model? It is known that any total, permutation-invariant function that can be computed in the one-way model but cannot be computed in the simultaneous model. See [FeldmanMSSS-06] for further details.